Undercover Reporting: Vote-buying caught on video

During a by-election held in April 2011 for the Malaysian parliamentary constituency of Batu Sapi in Sabah state, I went undercover to report on vote buying by the ruling coalition, and caught the illegal act on video.

It was an impromptu incident.  While covering an opposition campaign event in the town, I was chatting with a local resident who told me he just came over from another campaign activity organized by the ruling coalition where attendants were given cash money. I went to the venue and pretended to be a local voter, and, cha-ching! I received RM20 (US$6) from the campaigners and the best part was, I secretly recorded the process with my mobile phone.

After making sure I have collected all the necessary evidence, I revealed my identity and confronted a federal minister who was in-charge of that activity. She was surprised while her supporters became panic and started to surround me, threatening to do “naughty” things. I recorded the conversation between me and the conversation and left the scene before it turned ugly.

Unrelated to this incident, the minister, who was the top leader of the women wing of the largest ruling party, resigned from the government in 2012 after her family was accused of misusing public fund in the ‘Cowgate‘ scandal.

The original story was published here (paywall).


RM20 for workers… or voters?

4:21PM Apr 9, 2011

By Kuek Ser Kuang Keng

At an Umno Wanita community dinner function in Batu Sapi last night, RM20 was distributed to individuals who had registered their particulars with the organisers.

batu sapi bn vote buying photo 6 bn functionThis was video-recorded by Malaysiakini after receiving a tip-off from locals in the area that money was changing hands at a 40-table dinner function in SMK Agama Sandakan located in Taman Mawar, Batu Sapi.

Majlis Ramah Mesra, which was hosted by Wanita chief Shahrizat Abdul Jalil, was packed with BN supporters clad in party colours of blue, red and white sporting the familiar scale symbol and the Umno logo.

batu sapi bn vote buying photo 1Just before the event kicked off, however, individuals had queued up at a registration table to have their names, contact details and party affiliations recorded before getting ‘redeemed’ RM20 in cash.

Though the stage backdrop at the dinner stated that it was organised for members of Wanita Umno machinery, many of those in attendence were middle-aged Chinese men and women.

When asked as to why those queuing were in line, those interviewed – including one ‘aunty’ who said she is a voter – said they wanted to “collect money”.

“It is for voters. You need just to show your MyKad to prove that you are a voter in order to get the money,” said the lady.

‘Remember to vote for BN’

batu sapi bn vote buying photo 7 lining upIt was observed that many of those who had queued at the registration table left right after collecting the cash while those clad in BN uniforms found themselves seats at the table.

Some said they were being reimbursed for their “transportation expenses”. They declined, however, to say how much they were given each.

After recording his details at the table, even a Malaysiakinijournalist received RM20 without being questioned or even producing his MyKad. He was informed at the registration desk that everyone was given the same amount.

“Remember to vote for BN!” said one woman who was near the registration table to the journalist.

‘Don’t be naughty. They’re not voters’

When approached, Umno Wanita chief Shahrizat claimed that the RM20 was given as allowance for party campaigners.

batu sapi bn vote buying photo 3 giving moneyShahrizat, who was accompanied by Karambunai state assemblyperson Jainab Ahmad Ayid, told Malaysiakinithat she was unaware of the registration table, but later said that it was probably set up just to record the attendance of those at the function.

“I don’t know about that. I think this one must be for the registration,” she said.

Asked about the cash that was given away, Jainab interrupted and said curtly that the money was meant for “transportation”.

Below is a short transcript of the conversation, edited for clarity:

NONEShahrizat (left): Because these are jentera (party machinery). They are not the voters. They are from all over (the place).

Jainab: (Yes, they are) machinery… so we give them transportation (allowance).

Shahrizat: I know they from Kota Kinabalu, Kalabakan (and) all over. Tonight I (am) meeting (them), as you can see [pointing at the stage backdrop], (this function is for) the machinery. They are the ones going down (campaigning).

Shahrizat: I must make this clear (that) this is not vote-buying… You are (from) Malaysiakini? Please don’t do that to us because these women they come from all over Sabah.

They are the jentera. This is not… I didn’t even know about that.

Jainab: We are not voters. For your information, none of us are voters. We are here to work. So this is our machinery (and the money is) for transportation, that’s all!

Shahrizat: Don’t you naughty… if you say something like that we’ll do something like that also!